油土鳖评论：
1 Holding your other arrows in the same hand as your firing hand will help with speed shooting. Cool, but try shooting that fast with a traditional warbow that has 150 pounds draw weight, it is impossible (unless you can swing 150 pound dumbbells like they're cotton balls). That doesn't even account for the "trying to compensate for something" bows that have 200 pound draw weights.
2 The back quiver was NOT a Hollywood myth. back quivers were in historical war manuscripts AND contemporary art for centuries. Same for hip quivers.
3 Archers in the past DID train on stationary targets. Yes there were fancy mechanisms involving ropes and chains for moving targets, but they still practiced on stationary targets some of the time.
4 Hitting a blade so the arrow splits in half would mean your arrow didn't even have a head on it. If it did, that would be steel hitting steel and your knife would have a nasty dint in the edge.
5 Picking up arrows and shooting them back is kind of unlikely. An arrow from a war bow would be driven clean through an unarmored person or maybe 5 inches into a wooden shield. Standing there and struggling to pull it out to fire back is just a bad idea.
6 Grabbing an enemy's arrow and shooting it back was something difficult even for a robotic arm on Mythbusters, and it is ESPECIALLY unlikely using again, fucking war bows with 150 pounds of draw weight.
7 Using 1 hand vs both hands to fire a bow? THAT IS NOT HOW YOU FIRE A FUCKING BOW. Firing a bow properly uses both arms + your upper back, and that is something that all actual archers know from experience. Your back, if anything, is the MOST IMPORTANT muscle group, such that skeletons of British longbowmen were found to have warped spines due to repeated stress from years of archery.
For fuck's sake how am I the only expert here? You are all being duped! Just google Historical European Martial Arts and learn a thing or two.
更加详细的解释，基本的弓箭科普：
文章《Danish “Archer” Demonstrates Gullibility of Audience》
@nyplacnew 我真是不明白为何这么多人会认为那种扯淡的“历史”射箭技巧是真的，流言终结者以前做过一期节目证明过用箭矢射开另一只箭矢是不可能的，曾经有人尝试过接住正常弓箭射出的箭矢：最终达到了对射箭者90%的接中率，此时身上被钝箭射得鲜血淋漓，切换射箭者换成别人或者用正常的箭矢的话这个数据会更低
更不要说视频中的接住箭矢的部分完全就是剪接的射箭者连箭矢都没有使用
而其中科普的部分完全都是错的。
我的系列是打算写实的，这样有利于代入感，之前就有在看欧洲武术相关的科普和技巧了
1 Holding your other arrows in the same hand as your firing hand will help with speed shooting. Cool, but try shooting that fast with a traditional warbow that has 150 pounds draw weight, it is impossible (unless you can swing 150 pound dumbbells like they're cotton balls). That doesn't even account for the "trying to compensate for something" bows that have 200 pound draw weights.
2 The back quiver was NOT a Hollywood myth. back quivers were in historical war manuscripts AND contemporary art for centuries. Same for hip quivers.
3 Archers in the past DID train on stationary targets. Yes there were fancy mechanisms involving ropes and chains for moving targets, but they still practiced on stationary targets some of the time.
4 Hitting a blade so the arrow splits in half would mean your arrow didn't even have a head on it. If it did, that would be steel hitting steel and your knife would have a nasty dint in the edge.
5 Picking up arrows and shooting them back is kind of unlikely. An arrow from a war bow would be driven clean through an unarmored person or maybe 5 inches into a wooden shield. Standing there and struggling to pull it out to fire back is just a bad idea.
6 Grabbing an enemy's arrow and shooting it back was something difficult even for a robotic arm on Mythbusters, and it is ESPECIALLY unlikely using again, fucking war bows with 150 pounds of draw weight.
7 Using 1 hand vs both hands to fire a bow? THAT IS NOT HOW YOU FIRE A FUCKING BOW. Firing a bow properly uses both arms + your upper back, and that is something that all actual archers know from experience. Your back, if anything, is the MOST IMPORTANT muscle group, such that skeletons of British longbowmen were found to have warped spines due to repeated stress from years of archery.
For fuck's sake how am I the only expert here? You are all being duped! Just google Historical European Martial Arts and learn a thing or two.
更加详细的解释，基本的弓箭科普：
文章《Danish “Archer” Demonstrates Gullibility of Audience》
@nyplacnew 我真是不明白为何这么多人会认为那种扯淡的“历史”射箭技巧是真的，流言终结者以前做过一期节目证明过用箭矢射开另一只箭矢是不可能的，曾经有人尝试过接住正常弓箭射出的箭矢：最终达到了对射箭者90%的接中率，此时身上被钝箭射得鲜血淋漓，切换射箭者换成别人或者用正常的箭矢的话这个数据会更低
更不要说视频中的接住箭矢的部分完全就是剪接的射箭者连箭矢都没有使用
而其中科普的部分完全都是错的。
我的系列是打算写实的，这样有利于代入感，之前就有在看欧洲武术相关的科普和技巧了
但他不是世界最强的弓箭手，因为他的命中率并不算世界一流
